Alternatively titled:
Jon Might Be An AnimalThis is not a post about politics, sex, travel, buying stuff, or food.
It's not really a short post, I guess.
Some of you may know
JON, or be aware that I have a friend at work named
JON.
Jon posted an MSN conversation between him and I on his blog. Because I like people who read stuff, I've decided to also post the convo, but without the noisy distraction his blogger background provides (take That! Jon! -- Jon's like, "That That! Eyes!" hehe)
As Jon has done, I'm providing Webster's noun definition of 'instinct'.
instinct:
Inborn pattern of behavior often responsive to specific stimuli: "the spawning instinct in salmon"; "altruistic instincts in social animals".
And now, brought to you by time and space, the conversation two gerbils didn't have one day.
.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
do you relate success and profit to quality?Patrickman says:
its more like
you relate success and profit to a lack of qualityPatrickman says:
but what is quality?
.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
no i dont lolPatrickman says:
define qualityPatrickman says:
definitively
.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
quality is relative to each personPatrickman says:
zen and the art of motorcycle maintenance.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
lol
Patrickman says:
have you read it?.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
thats a real book?!Patrickman says:
its a very enlightening read as to how elusive quality is.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
oh, i know how elusive it is.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
thats why people think halo and halo 2 are good
.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
and WoW....
Patrickman says:
how elusive the definition of it is
.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
quality is on the same platform as beautyPatrickman says:
is it?
.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
yah.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
human nature has core beliefs what beauty is, and it differs from person to personPatrickman says:
rather than say i didn't know that, i will say i still don't know that
Patrickman says:
then it isn't core is it
.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
there are basic beliefs in beauty
.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
instincts persay
Patrickman says:
humans have no instincts
Patrickman says:
only animals do
.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
lol...
Patrickman says:
would you care to dispute that?
.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
thats a whole nother convo.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
hahaPatrickman says:
yes, but it's not a long convo.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
could bePatrickman says:
i'm interested to see what you consider to be instinctual in humansPatrickman says:
and i will show you that everything humans do is learned.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
every human is born w/ ideas and the capability to do certain thingsPatrickman says:
noPatrickman says:
they are not
Patrickman says:
no human is born with ideas
Patrickman says:
and there are no tasks that humans know innately.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
breathing is instinct
Patrickman says:
humans are the only mammal that cannot swim from birth
Patrickman says:
no it is not
Patrickman says:
breathing is not a taskPatrickman says:
eating isn't
Patrickman says:
sleeping isn't
Patrickman says:
these are all autonomic processes.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
so only task's can be considered instinct?
Patrickman says:
and are not considered instinct in any species
Patrickman says:
yesPatrickman says:
such as the instinct in birds to fly south in the winter without actually knowing where south isPatrickman says:
or how seals(?) use rocks to open clams etcPatrickman says:
or is it otters...::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
no idea
.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
lol.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
what about the instinct to look for protection from enviroments?.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
babies run to their mother's when they are scared
.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
well, not run.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
you know
Patrickman says:
babies are taught that mommy offers comfortPatrickman says:
but if it was instinct, how come you don't still run to mommy?Patrickman says:
instincts are never unlearned
.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
i still run to my mom.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
and yours.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
*burn!*
.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
what about fear?
Patrickman says:
autonomic
Patrickman says:
fight or flight
.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
most people are scared of spider's with out ever seeing one
Patrickman says:
the release of hormones into the blood stream will elevate certain statesPatrickman says:
no they are not
Patrickman says:
and saying they were...
.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
sex is an instinct
Patrickman says:
if fear was an instinct in humans, humans would react identically to the same situationsPatrickman says:
biological urges etc, are not task-related behavioursPatrickman says:
instinct, is knowledge applied without experience
.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
and bird flying south are biological urges?
.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
are not*
.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
wait.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
are*.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
no.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
are not*
Patrickman says:
they are not biological in nature.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
wtf.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
everything is biologicalPatrickman says:
well, sure
but flying south does not have the immediacy of biological imperitivesPatrickman says:
and behaviour is not a biological phenomenon.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
sex is a behaviour too thoPatrickman says:
at any rate, humans have no insticts. there is nothing we know how to do the first time we do it.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
its not purly physical like it was
.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
ok
.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
i got it.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
ill give you the fact that humans have no instinct.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
but i do have 1 we do have.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
humans have the instinct to learn
Patrickman says:
no we do not my friend
.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
omg
Patrickman says:
humans have the biological basis in order to store and reaccess memory
however, it is only with human culture that the process of real learning takes place
Patrickman says:
rats can "learn" a maze...
Patrickman says:
but rats cannot choose to learn
.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
culture? thats a shitty excuse
.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
what about cavemen?Patrickman says:
our learning is different because it starts off primitively, but gives way to consciousness through enculturation.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
there was no real culture when humans first came to be
Patrickman says:
excuse?Patrickman says:
the first humans only came to be as a result of culturePatrickman says:
the culture of communityPatrickman says:
the culture of recorded history
Patrickman says:
the culture of best practice
.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
fine, then culture is an instinct.
Patrickman says:
everything human relates to culture
Patrickman says:
omg
.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
BOOM!Patrickman says:
it is not
.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
AARRRGGGPatrickman says:
have you ever heard of the wild boy of aveyron?.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
no.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
wait, maybePatrickman says:
humans have a very brief window in which to become enculturated
Patrickman says:
after a certain point, it becomes impossible
Patrickman says:
thus, not an instinct.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
but even birds have to learn to fly
Patrickman says:
do they?.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
theyre taught, from their motherPatrickman says:
why do you think that is?Patrickman says:
i think you are incorrectPatrickman says:
mom has an instinct for when to push the birds out the nestPatrickman says:
however, birds fly with no demonstration of flight previously suppliedPatrickman says:
atfer a certain point, the instinct to fly matches with the physical capability to do so.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
what about when the mother demonstrates when she takes off from the nest
.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
or flys back
.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
the youth take noticePatrickman says:
haha
Patrickman says:
you make them sound so humanPatrickman says:
instead of just hungry needy mouths eagerly awaiting more food.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
PS - Patrickman says:yes, but it's not a long convo
.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
could be
Patrickman says:
relativity again?.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
im just trying to relate that humans, have certain built in notions
.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
Chuck has an instinct of round house kicking
Patrickman says:
omg
Patrickman says:
no they don't.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
walking!
Patrickman says:
humans have nothing more than biological dispositions to their environment
.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
yah, but the dispositions had to evolve from a notion.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
which would be an instinct
.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
what about the first human to walk?Patrickman says:
how so?Patrickman says:
dispositions had to evolve from a notionPatrickman says:
given that the disposition is biological, and notions are the result of cognizance....::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
cognizance?
.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
uh, dunno wtf that means
.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
dictionary.com to the rescue!
Patrickman says:
cognition
.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
you think notions are awareness?
.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
well, ok they are.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
nvm that.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
competition could be considered instinct...
Patrickman says:
well,
roll this all around for a while, and we will reapproach it on another occasion
agreed?Patrickman says:
it could not
Patrickman says:
peer accolades are only important to some.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
most*Patrickman says:
competition at the basest of levels is merely survival of the fittest.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
everyone wants to be the best
Patrickman says:
and survival is not a tast - it is a result
Patrickman says:
task*
.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
i know that.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
lol
.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
FINE
.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
lets drop it
.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
haha
Patrickman says:
we are not dropping itPatrickman says:
we are adjourning
.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
lol
.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
hmmmm
.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
adjourning...
.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
INSTINCT!.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
you know, i could do this for every verb in the dictionaryPatrickman says:
it is the result of thought processes learned from my species that i now direct my full attention to my work
.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
work is an instinct....
.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
ahaha
.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
jk
Patrickman says:
i luv u.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
lol.::Jon::. Canada 16 - Italy 0 Go GIRLS Go says:
im blogging this convo
Patrickman says:
thats a great idea
So what do you think? Do humans have what can be considered "Inborn pattern of behavior often responsive to specific stimuli"?
Consider my definitions of a couple things here in case you'd like to take issue with the support before the structure:
a "
pattern of behaviour" is no simple autonomic action or reaction such as breathing, feeding, and sleeping.
"
Inborn" means both independent of experience, and universal across a species.
Stay tuned for a post addressing "Is culture an organism unto itself? And, does it possess instincts?"
hehe Yeah, as if. Time for the Warcraft! hahahah